Dickle vs Tradle
Tradle is the closest thing Dickle has to a peer: both are daily puzzles built on a real published dataset with the source visible, and both are published by the people who hold the data. Tradle shows you a treemap of a country's exports and asks which country it is. Dickle names the country and asks for the figure. Same idea, opposite directions.
Side by side
| Dimension | Dickle | Tradle | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you guess | A published figure for a named country | Which country a treemap of exports belongs to | |
| Tradle gives you the data and asks for the country; Dickle gives you the country and asks for the data. Of everything in this genre these two are the closest pair. | |||
| Guesses | 5 guesses | 6 tries | Tradle |
| Where the numbers come from | Every figure is a published clinical measurement with the study named on the country's own page, two thirds of them linked to the paper on PubMed, and a third carrying a written note on what the study actually did and how it can be wrong | The Observatory of Economic Complexity's own trade data, which is the dataset the site exists to publish | |
| The only other game in this genre whose provenance is as good as ours, and arguably better: the publisher and the game are the same organisation. | |||
| Reading the data without playing | Every country has its own page with the figure, the study and the caveats, readable without playing | The whole Observatory — profiles, rankings and visualisations for every country — sits around the game | Tradle |
| We built a reference site around a game. Tradle is a game bolted onto a reference site that was already one of the best of its kind. | |||
| Countries covered | 24, limited by which have a primary study behind them | Effectively every trading country | Tradle |
| What is being tested | Whether you can put a number on something you have never looked up | Whether you can read an economy from what it sells | |
| Feedback | A hotter/colder warmth ladder — freezing, cold, warm, hot, scorching — set by how many centimetres out you are, plus higher or lower | Not stated | — |
| Past puzzles | Every past puzzle is replayable and cannot touch your streak | Not stated | — |
| Account needed | None. No backend, no sign-in; progress lives in your browser | None to play | |
| Cost | Free, with no premium tier and nothing to pay for. One ad slot, on the reveal after a round ends; the board itself carries none | Free to play, ad-supported, on a site that sells paid subscriptions for the underlying data | Dickle |
| Plays offline | Fully static. The puzzle data ships with the page, so it plays with a dropped connection | Not stated | — |
Where Tradle wins
Tradle does this better
- It is published by the people who own the dataset, which is a stronger provenance claim than ours: we cite other people's studies, they cite themselves.
- The Observatory around it is a genuinely excellent reference site with a profile for every country, and it existed long before the game did.
- Every trading country is in play, against our 24.
- Six tries rather than five, on an answer with far more possible values.
- As a thing to learn from, an export treemap teaches you more per puzzle than a single measurement does.
Play Tradle and judge for yourself. The link is not affiliated and the recommendation is real.
Where Dickle wins
Dickle does this better
- The number is the answer rather than the clue, which is the whole difference in what the two games test.
- Each country's page names the study, links it where the link has been checked, and says what that study actually did and how it can be wrong.
- A replayable archive that cannot damage your streak.
- Nothing sold behind the data, and the only ad is on the reveal after the round is over.
- Plays with the connection dropped.
Which should you play
Play Tradle if: Play Tradle if you want the puzzle attached to the better reference site, or if reading an economy from what it exports sounds more interesting than putting a number on a measurement. It is the most respectable game in this genre and we would recommend it over ours to anyone who cares about trade.
Play Dickle if: Play Dickle if you want the direction reversed: the country given, the figure withheld, and five guesses to find out how well calibrated you actually are.
Or both. They take about a minute each and they are not competing for the same minute of your day so much as this page implies. The full list of daily games has the rest of the genre, and methodology says where our own numbers are weakest.